Lenses: 18mm vs 18mm-55mm vs 14mm for travel?
  • MorrieCMorrieC
    Posts: 8
    I'm really curious how these lenses compare. 18mm 2.0 vs 18mm-55mm the zoom is 2.8 on the wide end vs the new 14mm lens. How is the image quality comparison? I would imagine the 14mm would be number 1.

    Is there really that much visible difference in the field of view between 14mm and 18mm?

    We are leaving for a trip to Vietnam in a few weeks and I'm trying to get my gear lined up. I will be taking a xe-1 with the 18mm-55mm lens, a 35mm 1.4 and a x100. Is it worth renting or buying a 14mm lens for this trip or am I covered with what I have?

    Any suggestions will be appreciated.
    Morrie
  • PK312PK312
    Posts: 19
    I have the 14, 18-55, 35 and 60. For a compact travel kit that suits my style of photography I always reach for the 14 and 35. Just outstanding image quality from those two (okay the 60 as well, but I only take two lenses when travelling). The 14 is much wider than the wide end of the zoom, and that can be both a challenge and a blessing. It really is up to your style of photography and for some the zoom on it's own will be all they need.
  • elithrarelithrar
    Posts: 56
    14mm on an X-E1: 80° horizontal FOV
    18mm on an X-E1: 66° horizontal FOV.

    So - a substantial difference at the wide end. But it may not matter if you don't like to shoot wide, and/or you like the convenience of the 18-55.

    (all of this stuff is personal choice)
  • WilzWorkz7WilzWorkz7
    Posts: 1,761
    Ultimately personal choice and personal shooting style. There is no right or wrong. There is no huge differences in terms of Image Quality unless you are anal about it.
    Featured:
    http://fujifilm-x.com/photographers/en/wilson_wong_us/

    Photo Blog + Projects + Gallery:
    http://wilzworkz.wordpress.com | http://www.flickr.com/photos/wilzworkz |

    Photo Club Singapore Photography Interest Network:
    http://groups.to/SPIN
  • karlbownkarlbown
    Posts: 117
    With most cameras the 18-55 kit lens is a cheap compromise to allow more cameras to be sold. With the Fuji version it seems they've gone a bit further than most manufacturers to ensure the lens is up to the standards of the primes. In fact some comparison with the 18mm have been in favour of the zoom. It's stuck on my X-Pro1 and I've been discouraged from getting the primes simply because the quality of the zoom is so good already.
    X-E1, 16-50, 50-230, X100S. Canon EOS-1ds Mk II, 28, 50. Also Pana G5, BMPCC
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/karlbown/
  • pominpocketpominpocket
    Posts: 2,037
    I personally would take the 35mm as it is the only lens I have . In your case I think you are very much covered with 35, zoom and 23 on x100. So I really would not bother with renting a lens .
    Fuji X100S
    Fuji XE1 35mm 1.4



  • gryphon1911gryphon1911
    Posts: 1,167
    Honestly, all the lenses that Fuji has put out to date are fantastic. I've seen a lot worse out there than the 18mm, which seems to be picked as one of the worst of the Fuji branded and released lenses.

    Worst, yes, maybe if we are comparing it to other lenses in the Fuji lineup. I can see that argument being made. I've got no complaints from the IQ I get from the 18mm.

    In normal shooting I don't see most people really having an issue with any of the IQ coming out of the Fuji lenses.
    Fuji X100
    Olympus OMD EM5, 17/1.8,45/1.8,40-150/4-5.6,12-50/3.5-6.3, 75-300/4.8-6.7
    Nikon N90s/D300/D700/Df, 24/2.8D, 50/1.8D, 80-200/2.8D, 300/4, 28-85/3.5-4.5 Tamron 90/2.8 Macro, 70-300/4-5.6VC Rokinon 8/3.5 Fisheye
    Mamiya C33 w/ 80/2.8, Kodak Signet 35, Zeiss Ikon Ikonta A 520, Graflex Speed Graphic, Voigtlander Brilliant
    Website | Google + | Facebook | Twitter | Visual Ohio Blog | Best Light Photo Blog | Visual Ohio Blog | Tumblr
  • PK312PK312
    Posts: 19
    elithrar said:

    14mm on an X-E1: 80° horizontal FOV
    18mm on an X-E1: 66° horizontal FOV.



    According to Fuji:

    14mm: 89 degrees

    18mm: 76.5 degrees

Hello Photographers!

Love your Fujifilm X-Pro1, X-E1, X-M1, X-A1, X100S, X100, X20, X10, X-S1, and XF1? We do too!

Join our community of fellow Fuji X Series photographers to learn more about your Fujifilm X Series digital camera, get great tips and give advice, show off your latest photographs, and share your experiences with these awesome cameras.

Photographers of all types and skill levels are welcome, sign in or create an account below to join in the discussions!

Login with Facebook Sign In with Google Sign In with OpenID Sign In with Twitter